Skip to main content

Ars Arcana Blog: Forking Paths in RPGs

Forking Paths in RPGs
Ars Arcana 2.3
Travis Joseph Rodgers

Roleplaying Games offer the possibility of solitude and solidarity. This might sound paradoxical. On one hand, however, RPGs afford something sometimes pejoratively called escapism. In an RPG, the players get away from things, or at least screen off things for a time being. The etymology of solitude is instructive: in its most extreme form, an RPG offers an escape for one. At the same time, RPGs offer solidarity: a shared, kindred experience. One of the ways this was accomplished in the past was by a sort of transgressive move: the adventure books and games in which individuals separately explored a foreign world then traded the books and experienced the world the other individual had experienced, though with some individual differences. I’ll call these Forking Paths, for the Borges story (strong recommend), and I’ll explain what they are and what value they still possess.

Forking Paths
In Jorge Luis Borges’s “The Garden of Forking Paths,” the structure of the multiverse is explored. The idea lent its name to a philosophy blog focusing on the discussion of human free will. The general idea is that our choices affect the world around us, opening some doors and closing others. Outside Borges (and perhaps including Borges), the most common example was the Choose Your Own Adventure books that my classmates and I adored back in the 80s. There were others, however, that took a step beyond merely allowing one to take an isolated adventure.
There was the Lone Wolf series of books, that allowed characters to continue on, saving up equipment as they progressed through the books. There was A Spy in Isengard that allowed characters to explore Tolkien’s Middle Earth, using a simple resolution mechanic. There were probably more in this vein, but I had moved on to college and grad school and, well, other things.

On the Merits of Forking Paths
Dungeon Chatter is going to be using a kind of Forking Paths for character creation. Traveller RPG has done this, and probably other systems have as well. So, it’s not unique; it’s just good practice. On one hand, if character creation is something that can be done solo, then a Forking Paths approach is good fun. It captures the nostalgia for a lot of us, and it transforms a process of reading and digesting rules into an interactive storytelling. On the other hand, Forking Paths can be a soft introduction to gaming and game mechanics for people who haven’t engaged in RPGs previously.
Judicious use of Forking Paths can essentially lead all players separately through a session zero. They could emerge with a character, fully created, a bit of background on their character, and a sense of where their characters are headed. They could experiment with different character concepts, backgrounds, builds, and the like, without having the pressure of time and eyes on them. The fact that these things are done separately was never a problem in the past for those of us who played them, and the coming together to discuss afterwards was always a joy.


Popular posts from this blog

Ars Arcana Blog 2.7: Creating a Character SPARK

Ars Arcana Blog: Bringing Your Character to Life with SPARK Travis J. Rodgers The Challenge(s) For the grizzled vet of RPGs, creating a character is often a struggle of too many options rather than not knowing where to start. The character concept comes easily to mind, either because there is a character the vet has been wanting to play or because vets often have served as GM as well as player for so long, character concepts seem to spring from an endless font. The challenge becomes determining which of the system options is the best way to make use of your character concept. Let’s call this the “How? Question” of character design. On the other hand, for the relative novice to Roleplaying, the challenge is two-fold. In addition, to the struggles of navigating a system’s options, the novice may not have, and may struggle to create, the character concept. Let’s call this new question the “What? Question” of character design. The SPARK In an episode of the Dungeon Chat

Ars Arcana Blog: Why No One Understands Alignment

Why No One Understands Alignment Travis J. Rodgers Alignment was introduced to Dungeons and Dragons as a character (NPC or PC) attribute. It wasn’t rolled for; it was typically selected, but sometimes a particular alignment was necessitated by the character’s race or class. But what is ostensibly a kind of “outlook” piece, cross-indexing a regard for law and chaos on one axis and good and evil on the other is at best a concept evolving across game versions. This fact would explain why long-time gamers, or at least gamers who have played multiple iterations of D&D, might view alignment differently from others. At worst, however, it’s essentially meaningless. There’s a middle path, which may be its original intent, one according to which alignment is both meaningful and quite objective – but then it’s extremely contentious. My considered view is that alignment is either meaningless or objective in a way that many players do not like (which is accurate is undertermined – the

Ars Arcana Blog: Spell Points, Slots, and Abilities

Ars Arcana Blog 2.4:  Spells: Points, Slots, and Abilities Travis Joseph Rodgers Do spellcasters in your game use spell points, spell slots, or can they call upon spells like other abilities (like climbing, throwing, and hacking)? Here are three potential problems your magic system will have to deal with and three approaches to solving those problems, with strengths and weaknesses of each approach considered. Part I: The Approaches These three approaches may not be exhaustive, but they do a good job of capturing the typical range of options one might see in an RPG. They are differentiated by the frequency one can cast and the relative customizability of the power of a “readied” spell. Spell Points (SP) Pool of points. Each spell has a cost. More points for more powerful spells. Systems: MERP, Role Master. E.g., Merlin and Magic Martha both cast “flame bolt” spell. Merlin easily pumps a dozen spell points into it, making it devastate his opponents. Martha fumbles